Here, we describe a 3D organotypic invasion assay adapted for the robust and accurate assessment of breast cancer cell invasion induced by CAFs [11-13]. This approach was originally developed as a 3D coculture model by Fusenig and colleagues [14], and further developed by other groups to study squamous cell carcinoma invasion [10, 15]. Briefly, CAFs are embedded in a dense gel composed of fibrillar collagen I and basement membrane matrix (termed Matrigel®, Cultrex®, or Engelbroth-Holm-Swarm matrix), which contains laminins, collagen IV, proteoglycans, and a broad spectrum of growth factors (see Fig.1). A thin layer of gel is used to cover the breast cancer cells seeded on the surface of the CAF-containing gel to mimic the physiological condition of breast tissue. Gels are subsequently laid on a grid and maintained partially immersed in cell medium. Organotypic gels are then fixed and processed by standard histopathological procedures followed by quantitative and qualitative analysis of breast cancer cell invasion using standard image processing and analysis software.
4T1 cells are a metastatic subpopulation of the original 410.4 murine breast cancer cell line [17].
For perturbation studies (i.e., RNAi), NFs/CAFs or cancer cells need to be modified before starting the protocol.
ATCC and other studies may suggest different media for culturing the breast cancer cell lines. However, we recommend using DMEM as the organotypic gels are based on it and it does not affect cell behavior or viability.
For puromycin, make aliquots of 10 mg/mL and store at −20 °C.
Preparation of 5× αDMEM (250 mL): dissolve 12.5 g DMEM powder (Gibco®) and 5 g NaHCO3 in 50 mL of sterile MilliQ water. Add 25 mL of sterile 1 M Hepes pH 7.5 and sterile MilliQ water up to 250 mL. Mix and filter the solution using a 0.2 mm filter in sterile conditions. Aliquot in 50 mL and 10 mL aliquots and store at −20 °C. Thaw fresh aliquots for gel preparation and do not store them longer than 30 days at 4 °C.
Rat tail collagen type I, high concentration is supplied as a liquid in 0.02 N acetic acid with a concentration range of 8–11 mg/mL. Note the actual concentration of each particular batch when calculating the volumes to be used during gel preparation (see Note 10).
Matrigel® is a viscous substance at 4 °C that solidifies at RT. Store Matrigel® in sterile 1 mL aliquots at −80 °C and thaw the amount required for an experiment the night before at 4 °C. Note the actual concentration of each particular batch, as it will be required to calculate the volumes for gel preparation (see Note 10). As an alternative to Matrigel® we have successfully used Engelbroth-Holm-Swarm matrix from Sigma-Aldrich in our organotypics.
We have used both murine and human CAFs in this assay. In our experience, murine CAFs require higher cell numbers than human CAFs, as the latter tend to be larger in size and have higher ECM remodeling abilities (see Note 13). For comparative studies, make sure an equal amount of NFs/CAFs are used.
To optimize the approach, it is recommended to empirically determine the effect of two variables: (1) the amount of NFs/CAFs to be embedded on the gel matrix; and (2) the length of the protocol (i.e., how long the fibroblasts are allowed to remodel the gels and/or the cancer cells are allowed to invade).
The final concentrations of collagen and Matrigel® in the gel are set to 4 mg/mL and 2 mg/mL, respectively. The recipe was optimized to have almost physiological concentrations of collagen I and Matrigel®. In order to prepare reproducible gel solutions the volumes of the components have to be adapted accordingly, depending on the stock concentrations of Matrigel® and collagen I (see Notes 6 and 7 ). For this protocol we base our volume calculations on stock concentrations of 10 mg/mL for both collagen I and Matrigel®. The volume of 5× DMEM can be adapted if larger volumes of the acidic collagen are added to retain optimal buffering.
Matrigel® and collagen I are very viscous and need to be pipetted with care. Avoid bubble formation (as bubbles can be detrimental to the quality of the gel) and retention of gel in the tips (as they may affect the final concentration).
Avoid leaving the gel mixture on ice for long periods of time as it may affect its properties.
For human NFs/CAFs , resuspend the pellet to a concentration of 2.5 × 106 (see Note 8).
To reduce the activating effect of FBS in fibroblasts, NFs/CAFs can be cultured for 5–7 days in fibroblast culture medium supplemented with 0.5% FBS (instead of 10% FBS) prior to the use in the organotypic invasion assay.
Cell-free gel will also be used for the nylon filter coating procedure (Section 3.3) and for covering the cancer cell layer on the top of the organotypic gel (Section 3.3).
Do not plate the total volume of the mix in order to avoid pipetting errors as the gel is very viscous and sticks to pipette tips. Gels can set at RT; these gels will not have the exact same properties as the ones set at 37 °C. We recommend keeping the 24-well plate on ice while adding the gel, especially when a larger number of samples are handled. This will allow the gel in all wells to set at the same time.
At this step, appropriate growth factors, cytokines or drugs can be added to the medium. Cell medium will buffer some of the acidity of the gels and may turn orange. For optimal results, replace with fresh medium after 2–3 h.
Seeding 100 μL of cell suspension on the top of highly contracted gels can be problematic. If needed, in these particular cases the empty space in the well can be covered up with fresh cell-free gel; this will allow cancer cells to be seeded on larger volumes (1 mL of 5 × 105 cell/mL suspension). However, the new gel only attaches loosely to the original gel and can sometimes rip off during the lifting process.
If gels have not contracted at all, cancer cells can also be applied in a volume of 1 mL per well (at 5 × 105 cell/mL).
Alternatively, depending on the type of carcinoma cells used in the assay, the cells can also be grown in an air–cells–liquid interface. The cells are prepared and added on top of the fibroblast-containing organotypic culture as described in Section 3.2. However, the cells will not be covered with a layer of gel.
At this step, appropriate growth factors, cytokines or drugs can be added to the medium, bearing in mind that they will affect both compartments (i.e., fibroblasts and cancer cells). The gels will become flatter during the incubation on the metal bridges.
Alternatively, gels can be snap-frozen for immunofluorescence analysis. Gels are placed in a plastic cuvette, covered by OCT buffer (Tissue-Tek) and immersed in liquid nitrogen. Store at −80 °C until further processing (see Note 25).
Keep the second half as backup until good H&E staining is obtained or use it to perform additional analysis (see Notes 22 , 24 and 25 ).
To allow for invasion analysis, gels must be embedded in paraffin in the correct orientation. Tissue sections need to be obtained from the cut side of the organotypic gel and not on the top or bottom sides. Sectioning the gel within the paraffin block can be challenging as the noninvasive cell layer can easily come off during processing. We recommend very slow trimming of the paraffin block at the first 500 μm to level the gel. Generate two to three cuts (50 μm apart) per organotypic gel per slide for analysis.
As an alternative to H&E staining, gels can also be processed for immunohistochemistry or immunofluorescence detection of specific cancer cell or CAF markers according to standard protocols (see Note 22). This will ascertain the cell identity of the invading cells. Alternatively, fluorescence-labeled cells can be used in the organotypic invasion assay to allow for detection without staining procedures.
Fibroblasts tend to concentrate on the borders of the gels, leading to artefacts on cancer cell invasion in those areas. Pictures need to be taken in the central part of the gel.
Other analysis can also be performed. For example, Alternative Invasive Index (invading area/non-invading area), number of invading objects, area of invading cells (without measuring gel areas), etc.
NFs/CAFs can be allowed to remodel the gel up to 10 days before the cancer cells are seeded on top. The length of this step has to be determined empirically if other models are used.
The choice of selection depends on the resistance genes expressed by the cells (e.g., selection-based stable RNAi/overexpression systems previously inserted). We recommend determining the optimal final concentration beforehand.
Thorough washing with PBS and medium is important; otherwise cancer cells added subsequently may be affected. If this becomes problematic, we recommend generating stable cancer cells resistant to the selective compound.